A Pure Lithium-branded metallic pouch-cell battery displayed on a white surface
A lithium-metal battery cell developed by Pure Lithium. Image shared by the company on LinkedIn; illustrative of its technology and not related to the government negotiations.

WASHINGTON — US Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick asked privately held battery developer Pure Lithium to give the federal government a 51% controlling stake in the company, in exchange for support for a proposed manufacturing plant, according to documents reviewed by Reuters and a person with direct knowledge of the discussions. The company rejected the proposal, which would have given Washington majority control without providing Pure Lithium with direct funding, Reuters reported on November 20.

Pure Lithium pouch-cell battery product
The company says its lithium-metal battery technology is designed to avoid graphite, nickel, cobalt and manganese. Company product image.

According to the Reuters investigation, Lutnick made the request during a July 29 meeting in Washington with Pure Lithium founder and chief executive Emilie Bodoin. The meeting was arranged by billionaire investor Robert Friedland, one of the startup’s largest shareholders, and was also attended by Commerce Department senior adviser David Shapiro. Lutnick reportedly argued that government control was necessary to make the company’s battery technology available to the US military and other federal agencies.

The proposal envisaged setting aside $1 billion from Japan’s previously announced $550 billion investment pledge to the United States for a manufacturing facility. However, the plant would have been owned by a special-purpose investment vehicle controlled by Washington and Tokyo rather than by Pure Lithium. The startup would have been contracted to operate the facility and receive a share of revenue after debt-servicing costs, but the documents reviewed by Reuters indicated that the company itself would receive no direct funding under the arrangement.

Lithium-metal battery cell associated with Pure Lithium
Pure Lithium’s battery cell. The proposed plant would have been owned by a US-Japan investment vehicle, not the startup itself.

Pure Lithium’s lawyers objected to the proposed ownership structure. In an August 22 memorandum reviewed by Reuters, law firm Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom warned that a 51% government stake was “far outside precedent” and could expose the company to public scrutiny, undermine its ability to attract private investment and jeopardise a future initial public offering. The company reportedly countered with a proposed 9.9% government stake, but the Commerce Department rejected that alternative and remained committed to 51%, according to the memorandum.

The company’s representative did not dispute Reuters’ account when asked about the proposal. The Commerce Department did not respond to the news agency’s questions. The White House also did not provide a response to Reuters. The report said Lutnick asked Pure Lithium to send 100 batteries to the departments of Energy and Defense for testing, as the administration considered the technology’s possible applications.

Pure Lithium branded battery cell
The battery technology is being developed for potential use in applications including defence, electric vehicles and energy storage. Image: Pure Lithium Corporation.

Pure Lithium describes itself as a vertically integrated lithium-metal battery technology company. On its official website, it says its batteries are designed to operate without graphite, nickel, cobalt or manganese and that its technology could serve markets ranging from drones and data centres to electric vehicles. Those performance and commercial claims are the company’s own; the technology’s ability to compete at large-scale commercial production has not been independently established by the reported government negotiations.

The negotiations also intersected with a legal dispute between Pure Lithium and Japanese electronics manufacturer Panasonic. Pure Lithium sued Panasonic in March, accusing it of reverse-engineering its lithium-metal battery technology. Panasonic disputes the allegation. Reuters reported that Lutnick suggested government control could help the startup in that dispute, with a hearing on Pure Lithium’s request for a preliminary injunction expected in January.

The meeting was organised by Friedland, whose company I-Pulse received a $250 million award from the Commerce Department in June. Friedland attended the July meeting but declined to comment through a spokesperson, Reuters said. The news agency reported that it had found no evidence Lutnick personally held a stake in either I-Pulse or Pure Lithium. A Commerce Department spokesperson, speaking on Lutnick’s behalf, said she did not think he was invested in either company.

The proposed 51% stake would have represented a significant escalation in the Trump administration’s efforts to take equity positions in strategically important US businesses. The administration has defended such investments as a way to strengthen domestic production and secure critical supply chains. Reuters noted that the largest equity stake the administration had agreed to at the time was a 15% position in rare-earth producer MP Materials; it had not secured majority ownership of a private company.

The use of federal funds and the legal authority for government equity ownership have also become subjects of political debate. The administration has pointed to funding associated with the 2022 CHIPS and Science Act, which was designed to support domestic semiconductor research and manufacturing. Critics in Congress argue that the law did not authorise the government to acquire ownership stakes in private companies. Reuters reported that no court had ruled on that legal question.

For Pure Lithium, the immediate outcome was a rejection of the proposed majority stake and a failure to agree on the company’s suggested minority alternative. The episode highlights the tension between the government’s push to secure access to emerging technologies and a private company’s desire to retain control, attract investors and determine its own route to commercialisation. No takeover was completed under the proposal described in the documents.

Support independent journalism: Help HeadlinesXtra continue delivering timely news, business reporting and independent journalism. Support HeadlinesXtra.