Central Park’s horse-drawn carriage industry is heading for a legal showdown with New York City after drivers and their union sued to block a new law phasing out the iconic tourist rides. The federal lawsuit was filed in Manhattan on Thursday, November 19, just minutes after Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed the legislation, escalating a long-running dispute over animal welfare, public safety and workers’ livelihoods.

The Transport Workers Union of America and TWU Local 100, together with a carriage medallion owner and two drivers, are asking a federal court to declare the ban unconstitutional and stop it from taking effect. The union argues that the city is threatening property rights, contracts and the livelihoods of people who have invested in the trade. The union’s account of the lawsuit says the challenge also questions the City Council’s authority and the procedures used to enact the measure. The Associated Press has independently reported the filing and the city’s response.
What The New York City Law Would Do
The measure, known as Romanch’s Law and enacted as Local Law 165 of 2026, sets a deadline for ending the horse-drawn cab industry. Under the law, New York City cannot issue new carriage-horse, horse-drawn cab or driver licences on or after June 1, 2028. Licences already active are due to expire permanently on May 31, 2028. The City Council’s official legislation record also requires humane arrangements for the horses and prohibits their sale or transfer for slaughter or use in another horse-carriage business.
The legislation followed the death of 18-year-old Indian tourist Romanch Mahajan, who was killed in a Central Park carriage incident earlier this year. City officials cited the tragedy, along with previous incidents involving horses becoming startled, collapsing or bolting, as reasons to end the industry. The New York City Council said the decision came after decades of debate over animal welfare and safety in a park visited by millions of people.
Drivers Say The Ban Threatens Their Livelihoods
Union leaders say the legislation does not adequately protect the people whose income depends on the carriage trade. TWU International President John Samuelsen has argued that owners paid substantial sums for city-issued medallions and should not lose the value of those assets without legally guaranteed compensation. The union’s statement describes the law as an unconstitutional taking and says the city’s approach could leave workers and owners facing major financial losses. Read the union’s statement.
At the same time, the city says it intends to help affected workers move into other employment. A framework announced by Mamdani’s office on November 17 includes a goal of facilitating medallion buybacks for owners, as well as career advice, job training, education pathways, entrepreneurship support and stipends for drivers and stable workers. The administration says a full transition plan is due by April 1, 2027. The Mayor’s Office outlined the proposed support programme.
However, the union’s central complaint is that the promised assistance is not sufficiently secured in the law itself. That difference is likely to become a key issue in the legal dispute: city officials are presenting the transition as a public-policy change accompanied by worker support, while the plaintiffs argue that the law itself imposes losses without adequate legal protection or compensation.
Mamdani Defends The Decision
At the City Hall signing ceremony, Mamdani acknowledged the historic role horses have played in New York but said the city’s streets and parks have changed. He argued that horses should no longer be required to pull tourist carriages through crowded Central Park alongside cyclists, runners and other visitors. “Our city has changed and now it is time for our laws to change, too,” he said, according to the Associated Press.
Animal-welfare advocates have welcomed the legislation, while supporters of the carriage industry say the rides are part of New York’s heritage and that better regulation could address safety concerns without eliminating the trade. The dispute therefore extends beyond the immediate question of employment, touching on how the city balances tradition, tourism, animal welfare and the rights of people whose businesses have operated under municipal licences.
Electric Carriages And The Future Of Central Park Rides
The Mamdani administration has also said it will commission a feasibility study examining whether electric carriages or pedal-assist bicycles could provide alternative visitor experiences inside Central Park, with electric carriages also considered for routes around the park’s perimeter. The proposal is part of the city’s wider transition framework, although no final replacement system has been selected. The city’s announcement says the study will explore possible alternatives.
The legal challenge now places the future of the industry partly in the hands of the federal courts. The city’s Law Department said it was reviewing the lawsuit, according to the Associated Press. Until a court rules otherwise or the law is changed, the statutory phase-out deadline remains June 1, 2028.
For New York, the case is likely to become a defining test of how a city can end a long-established industry while addressing the financial interests of its workers and owners. For carriage drivers, the immediate objective is to prevent the law from taking effect; for the mayor’s administration, the challenge is to defend the ban while delivering on its promises of a humane and financially responsible transition.
Support independent journalism: Help HeadlinesXtra continue delivering timely news, business reporting and independent journalism. Support HeadlinesXtra.