COLUMBIA, South Carolina — A South Carolina judge has denied Alex Murdaugh’s request to dismiss the original indictments accusing him of murdering his wife and younger son, clearing a major procedural hurdle ahead of his scheduled retrial in April 2027.

Circuit Judge Debra McCaslin issued the decision on Friday, November 20, following arguments from Murdaugh’s defence team and prosecutors over whether a state investigator gave misleading information to a grand jury when the charges were first brought. The ruling means the existing indictments remain in place. It does not decide whether Murdaugh is guilty of the killings. Associated Press report | ABC News coverage.

Defence challenged investigator’s grand jury testimony

Murdaugh’s lawyers had asked the court to throw out four indictments, arguing that former South Carolina Law Enforcement Division agent David Owen misrepresented important forensic details to the Colleton County grand jury in 2022. The defence focused particularly on statements about possible blood-spatter evidence on a white T-shirt Murdaugh wore on the night Maggie and Paul were killed, as well as the type of ammunition found in firearms on the family property.

Defence attorney Jim Griffin argued that the grand jury was told that blood spatter had been identified on Murdaugh’s shirt even though an earlier laboratory report did not identify human blood in the tested samples. The defence also disputed Owen’s account that other firearms found at the property were loaded with ammunition similar to the combination used in the fatal shooting of Paul.

Owen acknowledged during the original trial that he had told grand jurors about blood-spatter findings and that he had not seen an earlier report stating that no human blood had been identified on the shirt before the indictments were issued. He also acknowledged inaccuracies in his description of ammunition. He maintained that he had not intended to mislead the grand jury. CBS News’ account of the defence arguments and testimony.

Judge says disputed evidence can be examined at trial

In rejecting the request, McCaslin found that the defence had not established intentional investigative misconduct or shown that the disputed statements substantially influenced the grand jury’s decision. She concluded that the remaining evidence was sufficient to establish probable cause for the indictments to stand.

The judge nevertheless criticised the investigator’s failure to review the relevant report before presenting information about the shirt. She indicated that discrepancies and competing interpretations of forensic evidence could be explored during the retrial rather than used as grounds to dismiss the charges at this stage. WIS-TV report on the ruling.

Prosecutors opposed the dismissal motion, arguing that the grand jury had been presented with other evidence supporting the charges. They pointed to a video recorded on Paul Murdaugh’s cellphone that captured Alex Murdaugh’s voice at the family’s kennels shortly before the killings, as well as evidence concerning the family’s financial difficulties and the alleged theft of millions of dollars from clients.

What happened to Maggie and Paul Murdaugh?

Maggie Murdaugh, 52, and Paul Murdaugh, 22, were found shot to death on June 7, 2021, at the family’s property in Colleton County, in South Carolina’s Lowcountry. Alex Murdaugh, a former prominent attorney, was convicted in 2023 of their murders and sentenced to two consecutive life terms.

In May 2026, however, the South Carolina Supreme Court overturned those convictions and ordered a new trial after finding that former Colleton County Clerk of Court Becky Hill improperly influenced jurors during the original proceedings. The decision concerned the fairness of the trial; it was not a finding that Murdaugh had been cleared of the charges. Reuters report on the Supreme Court decision.

Murdaugh has consistently denied murdering his wife and son. He remains in prison on separate state and federal financial-crime sentences after admitting to stealing money from clients and other financial misconduct. Those convictions are distinct from the murder case and remain in place.

Retrial scheduled for April 2027

The retrial is scheduled to begin on April 5, 2027, in Sumter County after the court granted a change of venue. With the motion to dismiss denied, preparations can continue under the original indictments. Prosecutors had also indicated that they were prepared to seek fresh indictments if the existing charges were dismissed, but that step is no longer necessary following McCaslin’s decision.

The next stage will bring renewed scrutiny of the forensic evidence, the cellphone video, the investigation and the competing accounts presented by the prosecution and defence. The retrial will give a new jury the task of assessing the evidence and determining whether the state has proved the charges beyond a reasonable doubt.

Related Headlines

Support independent journalism: Help HeadlinesXtra continue delivering timely, sourced reporting. Support our newsroom.

Photo credit: Orange County Department of Corrections, October 14, 2021. Public-domain mugshot via Wikimedia Commons.