Ford, Honda, Stellantis and Volkswagen have filed a federal lawsuit seeking to block a New Jersey law that sets compensation rules for franchised dealers carrying out warranty, recall and other repairs. The automakers argue that the Motor Vehicle Open Recall Notice and Fair Compensation Act allows dealers to charge excessive labour rates and markups on parts, potentially increasing manufacturers’ costs without improving service for customers. The law took effect on April 1. Reuters reported the legal challenge.
The companies say the statute prevents manufacturers from managing repair costs and could shift more than $375 million annually to dealers. They also allege that some invoices included labour hours not actually worked and charges higher than those billed by comparable dealers or retail customers. Their lawsuit raises constitutional arguments and claims that federal recall rules override parts of the state measure. The New Jersey Coalition of Automotive Retailers, which is also named in the case, has defended the law, saying dealers should not be forced to absorb the costs of warranty and recall work. Reuters outlines both sides of the dispute.
The case could have implications beyond New Jersey if other states consider similar rules for dealer compensation and vehicle repairs. The outcome may affect the balance of power between manufacturers and franchised dealers, as well as the costs associated with recalls and warranty programmes. Consumers are not directly deciding the legal dispute, but changes in repair costs can ultimately influence vehicle prices and service networks. The lawsuit is at an early stage and the court has not ruled on the merits. The report includes the companies’ and dealers’ stated positions.
Related HeadlinesXtra Coverage
For further context, read Honda and Toyota’s separate global airbag recall.