JUNEAU, Alaska — The Trump administration has asked a federal appeals court to dismiss its lawsuit seeking to block certification of Democrat Mary Peltola’s victory in Alaska’s U.S. Senate race, moving to end a civil challenge that became moot after voters delivered a decisive result. The Justice Department filed its brief with the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Thursday, November 19, two days after the Associated Press projected Peltola as the winner. Alaska’s Division of Elections lists November 25 as the target certification date, and the appeal remains pending.

The department asked the appeals court to declare the case moot and dismiss it. Its filing also urged the court to vacate the lower court order that had rejected the government’s attempt to delay certification, then send the case back for dismissal. The distinction matters: the administration is not simply accepting the lower court’s reasoning; it is seeking to end the dispute while removing the adverse ruling from the record.

Official congressional portrait of Alaska senator-elect Mary Peltola.
Official portrait of Mary Peltola. Photo: House Creative Services; U.S. Congress public domain. Source and rights information.

How The Lawsuit Began

The civil case was filed before the November election at President Donald Trump’s direction. The Justice Department argued that Alaska should not certify a possible Peltola victory until officials could investigate whether voters had been confused by the presence of a second candidate named Daniel J. Sullivan, whose name resembled that of Republican incumbent Sen. Dan Sullivan.

The two candidates were listed separately on the ballot, with the challenger identified by his middle initial and without a party preference. Daniel J. Sullivan, a retired teacher from Petersburg, said he ran independently. Peltola has denied involvement in recruiting him, despite reports that campaign-linked figures discussed the idea. The allegations remain separate from the question of whether the government could legally delay certification.

The Alaska Supreme Court had previously affirmed the challenger’s right to appear on the ballot. A federal judge later dismissed the Justice Department’s civil lawsuit, finding that the government had not presented a workable way to investigate possible voter confusion while protecting the secrecy of individual ballots. The state of Alaska, which is controlled by Republicans, also opposed the federal challenge and described it as legally meritless.

The Alaska State Capitol building in Juneau.
Alaska State Capitol, Juneau. Photo: Jay Galvin; Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 (CC BY 2.0). Source and licence.

Peltola Won An Outright Majority

The Associated Press called the race for Peltola on November 17 after she secured 50.1% of first-choice votes, enough to avoid a ranked-choice tabulation. The state’s official election page still identifies the figures as unofficial and lists November 25 as the target certification date. The DOJ’s latest filing does not certify the result; it argues that the case has become moot because ballots cast for the two Sullivan candidates have been mixed together and can no longer be identified individually.

In response to the latest filing, Peltola said voters had delivered a clear message and that she was ready to move forward and work for Alaskans. Her victory is part of the wider 2026 midterm shift that gave Democrats control of the Senate. HeadlinesXtra previously reported on Peltola’s victory and the change in the Senate balance.

Panoramic view of Juneau, Alaska, the state capital.
Panorama of Juneau, Alaska. Photo: Gillfoto; Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 (CC BY-SA 3.0). Source and licence.

Civil Case Moves Toward Closure, But Criminal Probe Continues

The request to end the civil appeal does not resolve every investigation connected to the campaign. The Washington Post reported that a separate federal criminal investigation into the alleged recruitment effort remained active. Peltola has denied knowledge of any recruitment scheme, and Daniel J. Sullivan has said he ran independently. No criminal charge had been reported in the sources reviewed for this article.

The Justice Department’s November 19 brief says the case is now moot because the ballots have been commingled and there is no longer a way to determine whether votes for Daniel J. Sullivan were intended for the incumbent. It asks the 9th Circuit to vacate the district court’s dismissal and remand for the case to be dismissed as moot. The appeals court has not yet ruled on that request.

HeadlinesXtra Analysis

The latest filing closes one of the most unusual legal disputes of the 2026 midterm cycle, but its implications extend beyond Alaska. The case raised questions about how far federal officials can go in seeking to delay state election certification, particularly when the proposed investigation would require access to information protected by ballot secrecy.

The administration’s request is also carefully framed. By seeking vacatur as well as dismissal, the Justice Department is trying to avoid leaving the lower court’s reasoning intact as a precedent. The appeals court’s response will determine whether the civil case ends on procedural grounds or leaves a more lasting judicial explanation of the limits on federal intervention in state election administration. The separate criminal inquiry should be assessed on its own evidence and should not be treated as proof of wrongdoing by any candidate.

Sources and Further Reading