ANTALYA, Türkiye — Countries negotiating at the United Nations climate conference COP31 are increasingly confronting the possibility that the world will need to remove large quantities of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, in addition to cutting emissions, to limit the long-term effects of global warming. Draft conclusions discussed as the summit entered its final scheduled day acknowledge that the planet is likely to exceed the Paris Agreement’s 1.5°C temperature threshold and may require large-scale carbon removal to bring warming back down. The issue was highlighted by the Associated Press on November 20.

A Climeworks installation designed to capture carbon dioxide directly from the air in Bern, Switzerland
Photograph by TRx340, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0. The installation was photographed in 2015. Image source and licence.

The United Nations estimates that approximately 320 billion metric tonnes of carbon dioxide may need to be removed this century to return global temperatures below the 1.5°C limit after an overshoot. That volume is equivalent to roughly eight years of current global emissions, according to the AP report. The estimate highlights the scale of the challenge facing governments, scientists and industry as climate impacts intensify and countries struggle to agree on faster reductions in fossil-fuel pollution.

Carbon dioxide removal covers a range of approaches, from restoring forests and wetlands to extracting carbon directly from the air and storing it underground. Some methods seek to accelerate natural processes that absorb carbon, while others use industrial equipment to filter carbon dioxide from ambient air. The technologies differ in cost, permanence, energy requirements and potential environmental effects.

Direct Air Capture Remains Small Compared With The Challenge

Direct air capture uses fans and chemical filters to draw air through equipment that separates carbon dioxide from other gases. The captured carbon can then be stored underground or used in industrial processes. The technology is attracting investment and research, but its current deployment remains limited. The AP report said technological direct-air-capture facilities have removed about two million tonnes of carbon dioxide, while total carbon removal is estimated at around two billion tonnes annually, almost all through reforestation.

Carbon capture equipment at the Heidelberg cement factory in Brevik, Norway
Photograph by PutTheKettleOn, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0. The installation was photographed in November 2024. Image source and licence.

Carbon capture and storage at industrial facilities is related but different. It captures carbon dioxide before it enters the atmosphere, for example from cement production or other industrial processes, while carbon dioxide removal extracts carbon already present in the air. The distinction matters because the two approaches serve different roles in climate policy. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change’s mitigation assessment explains how carbon capture and removal feature in different pathways for reducing greenhouse-gas emissions.

Costs And Technical Barriers Remain Significant

Scaling carbon removal to the levels discussed in climate scenarios would require major investment, new infrastructure, large amounts of energy and reliable systems for storing carbon permanently. The AP report said the effort could cost tens of trillions of dollars over the century. Existing direct-air-capture systems remain far smaller than the capacity needed, and several companies in the sector have struggled to attract the financing required for expansion.

Storage is another central issue. Captured carbon must be kept out of the atmosphere for a sufficiently long period to deliver a lasting climate benefit. Geological storage requires suitable underground formations, monitoring and safeguards against leakage, while biological approaches such as tree planting can be affected by drought, fire, land-use change and disease. The International Energy Agency’s direct air capture analysis outlines the energy, cost and infrastructure challenges facing the technology.

Scientists Warn Against Treating Carbon Removal As A Substitute

Scientists and environmental advocates have warned that carbon removal should complement, not replace, rapid reductions in fossil-fuel emissions. If governments rely too heavily on future technology, they risk delaying action that can reduce pollution immediately. The AP report said researchers and officials at COP31 stressed that carbon removal cannot compensate for unlimited emissions or make it safe to continue burning fossil fuels at current rates.

The concern is also reflected in the negotiating text. The draft calls for carbon dioxide removal to support the long-term temperature goal while stating that it must not substitute for or delay deep emissions reductions. Reuters reported that a revised COP31 draft removed explicit references to transitioning away from fossil fuels, while retaining language encouraging carbon capture and removal technologies. The Reuters report on the negotiations described the divisions among countries over the role of electrification, fossil fuels and carbon removal.

Environmental And Social Questions

Large-scale carbon removal could require land, water, energy and transport infrastructure. Some approaches that rely on growing biomass for energy and then capturing the resulting carbon could compete with food production or affect biodiversity if poorly planned. Ocean-based approaches also raise questions about ecological impacts and how much carbon is actually removed and stored over time. Scientists have said that more research is needed to establish the effectiveness and environmental safety of some proposed methods.

At COP31, advocates for Indigenous communities and environmental organisations warned that carbon projects could affect land rights and local livelihoods if communities are not consulted and safeguards are weak. The New Scientist report described concerns about land requirements, water use and the influence of carbon-capture industry lobbyists at the talks.

Negotiators Face A Difficult Climate Agreement

The carbon-removal debate is unfolding alongside disagreements over fossil-fuel phase-out language, climate finance and support for countries most exposed to extreme weather. COP31, hosted in Antalya, Türkiye, is scheduled to end on November 20, although previous climate conferences have often continued beyond their official deadline while negotiators seek consensus. The Guardian’s live coverage described deep divisions over finance, adaptation and the wording of the final agreement.

Australia and Türkiye are leading the negotiations under a split presidency arrangement. More than 190 countries are represented, and any final decision will require broad agreement. The revised draft is not a final outcome, and its language may change before countries approve the closing text. Reuters said the latest version removed direct references to fossil fuels, a change that has drawn criticism from campaigners and some governments.

HeadlinesXtra Analysis

The growing focus on carbon removal reflects a difficult scientific and political reality: the world has delayed emissions reductions for so long that some future removal may be necessary to limit the duration and severity of temperature overshoot. However, the technology is not yet available at the scale required, and the costs and environmental consequences remain uncertain. Carbon removal should therefore be treated as a supporting tool rather than a reason to postpone immediate cuts in pollution.

The most credible climate strategy will combine faster renewable-energy deployment, improved energy efficiency, protection and restoration of natural ecosystems, reductions in methane and other greenhouse gases, and carefully governed carbon removal for emissions that are difficult to eliminate. Governments must also ensure that projects respect local communities and deliver measurable, durable results. HeadlinesXtra will continue to follow the COP31 negotiations and climate science, including our recent report on NASA’s new 3D maps for California wildfire-risk assessment.

Sources And Further Reading