NEW YORK — A photograph showing a pigeon perched on a hospital patient has circulated widely online alongside an emotional story claiming the bird repeatedly visited a man whose family had not come to see him. But the touching account is not true, according to fact-checkers who traced the image to a chance encounter photographed in Greece in 2013.

A pigeon perched on a hospital patient lying in bed
The photograph was taken in 2013 in an Athens hospital. The viral claim that the pigeon regularly visited the patient has been debunked. Photo supplied for this fact-check.

The viral caption, which has appeared in different versions on social media, says a nurse noticed that a pigeon returned to a patient’s bedside every two days. It further claims hospital staff later discovered that the man had regularly fed pigeons at a nearby park, prompting the bird to visit him while he was hospitalized.

However, Lead Stories reported in January 2021 that the story was false. The photograph was taken by Ioannis Protonotarios, a photographer and independent filmmaker based in Athens, Greece—not by a nurse.

Photographer Explains How The Picture Was Taken

Protonotarios told Lead Stories that he was visiting his father in a cardiology ward at an Athens hospital when he noticed a pigeon resting on a sleeping patient in a nearby bed. He quickly photographed the unusual moment before the bird flew away.

The original photograph was posted to his Flickr account on October 19, 2013, years before the nurse-and-pigeon story began spreading online. The Quint independently examined the image in September 2020 and also identified Protonotarios as the photographer.

No Evidence Of Repeated Visits Or Family Abandonment

There is no reliable evidence that the pigeon returned to the patient’s bedside every two days, that the man had previously fed the bird in a park, or that his relatives failed to visit him. Those details are part of the false caption attached to the photograph.

USA TODAY’s fact-check likewise concluded that the image was genuine but the story circulating with it was false. The photographer said he never saw the patient or pigeon again after the brief encounter.

Why The Story Keeps Resurfacing

The image is striking, and the accompanying message taps into familiar themes of loyalty, loneliness and kindness. That emotional appeal may help explain why the claim continues to resurface, even after it has been investigated and debunked.

The photograph can still prompt reflection on compassion and the bond people form with animals. But sharing that message does not require presenting an invented account as fact. The verified story is already unusual: a photographer visiting his father noticed a pigeon resting on another patient and captured the moment.

HeadlinesXtra fact-check: The photograph is authentic. The claim that a pigeon repeatedly visited an abandoned patient because he had fed it in a park is unsupported and has been debunked.