Country music stars Jason Aldean and Luke Bryan are pushing back against a $1.4 million legal claim connected to the closure of E3 Chophouse, their former Nashville steakhouse venture. In separate but nearly identical court responses, the singers deny that they are personally responsible for the damages sought by the landlord and are asking the court to dismiss the claims against them. TMZ, citing court documents, reported the latest filings on November 16, while Digital Music News also detailed their legal position.

Jason Aldean at AmericaFest in Phoenix in December 2025
Jason Aldean speaking at AmericaFest in Phoenix, Arizona, on December 19, 2025. Photo: Gage Skidmore / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0. Source and licence.

The dispute centres on E3 Chophouse, which Aldean and Bryan launched in Nashville in 2019 alongside former Major League Baseball player Adam LaRoche. The restaurant, located in the city’s Hillsboro Village neighbourhood, announced in February 2026 that it was temporarily pausing operations while its owners considered market opportunities and the possibility of a rebrand or a new concept. The original E3 Chophouse in Steamboat Springs, Colorado, is a separate location. Digital Music News and PEOPLE have reported on the restaurant’s closure and ownership.

Luke Bryan photographed in 2014
Luke Bryan photographed on March 2, 2014. Photo: Joe Bielawa / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0. Source and licence.

The landlord’s case follows a default judgment of approximately $1.427 million against the restaurant’s operating company over unpaid rent and related costs. The landlord alleges that rent payments stopped and the restaurant closed before the commercial lease was due to expire in August 2029. The legal action seeks to extend responsibility to Aldean, Bryan and LaRoche on the basis that they personally guaranteed obligations under the lease. ABC15’s report on the original claim outlines the landlord’s allegations and the earlier judgment.

The singers’ defence challenges how the lease guarantee should be interpreted. According to Billboard’s report, republished by PressBee, the October filing argues that the guarantors’ rent obligations lasted for only five years. Their lawyers contend that after that period, any remaining exposure should be limited to a portion of the construction allowance that had not yet been amortised. They calculate that amount at approximately $59,000, rather than the full $1.4 million being pursued.

Their legal team also argues that the landlord’s claimed damages are speculative, uncertain and not recoverable under the terms of the guarantee. In their latest responses, Aldean and Bryan further contend that the landlord failed to take reasonable steps to minimise its losses. They are asking the court to reject the claims, although the arguments remain their legal position and have not yet been accepted as a final ruling. TMZ’s account of the responses describes the singers’ objections.

LaRoche is also part of the wider dispute, having joined the singers in the restaurant venture and in the argument over the scope of the lease guarantee. The case is expected to return to court in January 2027, when the judge will consider the parties’ competing positions. Until the court rules, the $1.4 million judgment against the operating company should not be confused with a final personal judgment against Aldean or Bryan. Digital Music News and Billboard’s reported filing details provide the latest available account of the legal timetable and defence arguments.

The case highlights the financial and legal risks that can accompany celebrity-backed hospitality businesses, particularly when commercial leases include personal guarantees. For Aldean and Bryan, the immediate issue is whether the guarantee exposes them to the full amount claimed by the landlord or whether the contractual cap limits their potential liability to a much smaller figure. The court’s eventual interpretation of the agreement will determine the next stage of the dispute.

Photo credits: Jason Aldean — Gage Skidmore / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0. Luke Bryan — Joe Bielawa / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0. Both photographs are licensed for reuse with attribution and are not images of the court proceedings or restaurant closure.