SEO Subtitle: New analysis of Indeed labour-market data finds that 50% of the 2025 graduating class were working in jobs that did not require a bachelor’s degree one year after leaving college, highlighting a difficult entry-level job market.
WASHINGTON, November 22, 2026 — About half of Americans who graduated with bachelor’s degrees in 2025 were working in jobs that did not require a college degree 12 months after graduation, according to a new analysis published Sunday by Business Insider, adding to concerns about the employment prospects facing young professionals.
The analysis, based on data from job-search platform Indeed, found that 50% of the class of 2025 were underemployed a year after graduation. That compares with an average of 39% among graduates in the 2017–2019 period, before the pandemic disrupted education and employment patterns. Business Insider’s November 22 report says the trend reflects a challenging market for people seeking their first professional roles.

Underemployment is different from unemployment. It describes graduates who have found work but are employed in occupations that typically do not require the degree they earned. Such roles can provide income and work experience, but may not use a graduate’s specialist training or offer the same career progression and earnings associated with degree-level employment.
Indeed economist Sneha Puri attributed the rise to a low-hire, low-fire labour market, in which employers are making fewer new hires and experienced candidates are competing for some entry-level positions. Business Insider reported that employers have increasingly favoured applicants who can contribute immediately, while postings for entry-level roles have declined and attracted heavy competition.

The pressure is especially significant for new graduates because many are applying for their first full-time professional jobs. When employers seek prior experience even for junior positions, graduates can find themselves competing with applicants who have already spent several years in the workforce. The result can be a prolonged transition from education into a career that matches a graduate’s qualifications.
The consequences may extend beyond the first year after graduation. Business Insider cited a 2024 report from the Burning Glass Institute and Strada Institute which found that 73% of graduates who began their careers underemployed remained so a decade later. The report also found that those graduates were about 3.5 times more likely to remain underemployed than peers who started in jobs requiring a college degree.

Employment outcomes also differ by field of study. The report said criminal justice, performing arts and fine arts graduates recorded some of the highest underemployment rates in 2024, while nursing, aerospace engineering and civil engineering graduates were among those with the lowest. However, a degree’s employment prospects can vary with location, demand, experience and the specific occupation being pursued.
Data from the Federal Reserve Bank of New York offers a broader view of the pressure on young graduates. Its latest quarterly update, released November 2, showed that unemployment among recent college graduates aged 22 to 27 fell to 5.2% in the third quarter of 2026, while their underemployment rate edged up to 42.5%. The figures use a different measure and population from Indeed’s class-of-2025 analysis, so they should not be treated as identical statistics. The NY Fed’s college labour-market tracker provides the underlying series and definitions.

The income gap between degree-level and non-degree-level jobs can also affect graduates’ ability to repay student loans, build savings and establish financial independence. Business Insider cited 2025 Bureau of Labor Statistics figures showing that retail salespeople earned an average annual wage of $37,310, compared with $69,770 across occupations. It also noted that entry-level software engineers averaged about $82,000, although pay varies by employer and location.
The figures do not mean that a university degree has no value, nor that every graduate will struggle to find a professional position. They do, however, raise questions about how well higher education, employers and career services are preparing students for the transition into work. Employers’ willingness to train early-career applicants, the availability of paid internships and the alignment between course content and workforce needs are likely to influence future outcomes.

For students choosing courses and graduates planning their next steps, the findings underline the importance of researching employment outcomes by major, building practical experience and developing skills that employers can assess. For policymakers and universities, the challenge is to ensure that qualifications translate into meaningful opportunities rather than leaving large numbers of graduates in jobs that do not make use of their education.
Sources: Business Insider; Yahoo Finance syndication; Federal Reserve Bank of New York.
Support independent journalism: Help HeadlinesXtra continue delivering timely news, business reporting and independent journalism. Support HeadlinesXtra.