Hollywood relationships can survive decades of changing careers, shifting friendships and public attention. But Christina Ricci believes one unanswered voicemail may have left her relationship with music icon Cher frozen for almost 27 years. The actress recently revealed that she has not been in contact with her former Mermaids co-star, and suspects the silence began after she failed to return a call when she was 19. People and Entertainment Weekly reported her account following her television appearance.

Cher and young Christina Ricci sharing a candid moment with Winona Ryder during the filming of Mermaids.
Cher and Christina Ricci share a moment on the set of the 1990 film Mermaids. Photo: MGM / via OK! Magazine.

The Voicemail That Ricci Says Changed Everything

During an appearance on Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen on November 17, Ricci was asked whether she still kept in touch with Cher. The Yellowjackets actress answered that they were no longer in contact and joked that the legendary singer was still upset with her. Ricci described the situation as a long-running grudge, according to E! News.

Ricci recalled that when she was 19, she took part in a magazine-related interview in which Cher was also interviewed. She could not confidently remember whether the publication was Rolling Stone or Première, but said the resulting comments made it appear that Cher had said unflattering things about her.

According to Ricci, Cher subsequently left her a voicemail to explain that journalists sometimes select the most negative parts of conversations and to apologise for the impression created by the article. Ricci admitted that she was young at the time and did not return the message. She now believes that failure to respond may have hurt Cher and contributed to the breakdown in contact. TV Insider also detailed the exchange.

Ricci Says Later Attempts To Reconnect Went Unanswered

The actress told Cohen that she has tried to reach out to Cher in the years since the incident, but says those efforts have been met with silence. Her explanation remains her own interpretation of the situation; Cher has not publicly confirmed Ricci’s account, and reports said a response from the singer’s representative had not been received at the time of publication. Entertainment Weekly noted that it could not immediately obtain comment from Cher’s representative.

Despite the apparent distance, Ricci made it clear that she does not hold a grudge against her former co-star. Instead, she said she adores Cher and can understand why the singer might have felt disappointed after making an effort to explain the magazine story directly to a young colleague, only for the call not to be returned. Ricci even addressed Cher directly during the conversation, expressing love and admiration for her. Us Weekly published further details from the interview.

A Bond That Began On The Set Of Mermaids

Cher and Ricci first worked together on the 1990 film Mermaids, a comedy-drama in which Cher played Rachel Flax, a single mother, while Ricci portrayed her younger daughter, Kate. Winona Ryder played the older daughter, Charlotte. The film introduced audiences to Ricci as a young performer and established a connection between the two actresses that Ricci has spoken about warmly over the years.

In the 2024 documentary Child Star, Ricci praised Cher for looking out for her during filming. She recalled that Cher helped her understand the complicated dynamics that can exist behind the scenes on a film set, making sure the young actress did not blame herself or feel insecure about situations she could not fully understand. Entertainment Weekly revisited those comments in its report on the latest revelation.

Could A Simple Apology Reopen The Door?

Ricci’s story has struck a chord because it centres on a small moment that may have carried a much larger meaning for both women. At 19, she may not have understood how important Cher’s personal explanation was to the singer. Looking back as an adult, Ricci says she can see why the unanswered voicemail might have been upsetting.

For now, there is no public indication that the two have reconciled, and the full account of the disagreement has come from Ricci rather than from both sides. Still, her affectionate message suggests that she would welcome a fresh start. Whether Cher chooses to respond remains to be seen, but Ricci has made one thing clear: the admiration she developed for her former screen mother has survived the long silence.

Source note: This report is based on Christina Ricci’s November 17 television appearance and coverage by People, Entertainment Weekly, E! News and TV Insider. The magazine interview Ricci recalled has not been independently identified in the available reporting.